Mister Pizza Elmwood

3.8 ( 1126 reviews )
Checking... 9:00 AM - 1:00 AM See Hours
$10–20
1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States
+1 716-882-6500

Mister Pizza Elmwood, located at 1065 Elmwood Ave in Buffalo, NY, has carved out a reputation as a go-to destination for pizza lovers. Customers rave about their flavorful offerings, particularly the BBQ wings and specialty pizzas, which are frequently described as "delicious" and "the best pizzeria in WNY." Many reviews highlight the friendly service, from the courteous staff who take orders to the prompt delivery, making every dining experience enjoyable.

Nelson Newman fondly recalls the mouthwatering taste of their wings and pizza, while Erica Martone emphasizes the consistent quality and friendly greetings she receives with each visit. Even Peter Hall quips about the lack of ambiance, noting that the focus here is entirely on the food—a sentiment echoed by families like Jeff Transki's, who celebrate events with Mister Pizza's offerings.

The reviews also commend the attention to special requests, ensuring that customers receive exactly what they ordered—hot and fresh. Although some slight tweaks are recommended, like perfecting the fries, the overall consensus is clear: Mister Pizza Elmwood is a staple for anyone seeking hearty, satisfying pizza delivered with care.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Late-night food
    • Quick bite
    • Vegetarian options
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Counter service
    • Dessert
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Trendy
  • Crowd
    • LGBTQ+ friendly
    • Tourists
    • Transgender safe space
    • University students
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot

Reviews For Mister Pizza Elmwood

Nelson Newman
Jun 26,2025
Food was absolutely Delicious, just as I remember. It's been awhile since order out.It sure hit the spot! BBQ wings and Pizza. The Bomb! I had great service from calling and ordering my food, to the delivery service when my food was delivered. My food was still hot. They were all helpful and polite. Thank you Mr.Pizza! See you again soon. Robin D.
Erica Martone
May 29,2025
I frequent this place too much tbh. Always a friendly greeting and food is consistently good. I get slices often but getting the whole pie is where it’s at. I get the specialty crusts for a little extra somethin’
Peter Hall
May 28,2025
I love (ha ha) the generic form with “Atmosphere” as a quality to rate. NOBODY goes to Mr. Pizza for a dine in experience! In fact, we wouldn’t have it any other way. IT’S THE FOOD! Our medium C&P pizza (with garlic sesame crust) and 10 wings were perfect. The guy on the phone was friendly and same with pickup.
Jeff Transki
May 4,2025
Tony and his employees provided us a fantastic meal for my son’s hockey team party!! All the parents & kids loved the pizza & wings especially the Chiavetta’s wings!! The delivery was prompt and the price was just right. Thank you Tony and staff keep up the great work!!
SPBESQ
Apr 16,2025
I’ll disclose that we are Mister Pizza customers, and we keep returning for one reason: when they are on their game, they are simply the best pizzeria In WNY. They had there A game today! I ordered by phone and the man who took my order was prompt, pleasant, handled our special order with no problem, and we picked up exactly what we ordered. What more can you ask for? Taste you say? Well, when we got home, the pie was exactly how we ordered it and it tasted great. Fingers were prepared to perfection. My only criticism is that the fries were a little overdone - something to work on for next time.
David Book
Apr 11,2025
My order was delivered fast and fresh my grandkids love Mister pizza and so do I the chicken fingers were also Fresh and hot A great meal on a short notice they estimated my delivery an hour and a half hours and they were there in 30 min.
Michelle Stevens
Mar 30,2025
For traditional pizzas we’ve been customers of Mister Pizza on Elmwood for almost 40years. Not only do they make a delicious Pizza Pie, this LOCALLY OWNED pizzeria continually support's our community! In my personal community activities they have supplied school grade level fundraisers, city wide school and sport events at a great price. Theses folks care about the quality of their products and their community! I highly recommend them
Tami Dalton
Mar 24,2025
The service there is very good and friendly. Their food was great and hot upon arrival. They even went beyond to meet what I wanted. And it was delicious.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

El Taco
(682 review)
El Taco
  • 306 Victoria St, Nelson, BC V1L 1N2, Canada
Mexican restaurant
+1 250-352-2060
acquafarina
(825 review)
acquafarina
  • 425 W Georgia St, Vancouver, BC V6B 5K5, Canada
Italian restaurant
+1 604-558-3099
Ferrandos - Whiskey
(848 review)
Ferrandos - Whiskey
  • 152 S Aiken Ln, Aiken, SC 29803, United States
Italian restaurant
+1 803-644-8881
Palapa Campestre
(280 review)
Palapa Campestre
  • Carretera Amealco-Galindo Km 31, San Martin, 76844 Amealco de Bonfil, Qro., Mexico
seafood restaurant
+52 442 185 9628
Mi Linda Tierra Taqueria (MLT)
(405 review)
Mi Linda Tierra Taqueria (MLT)
  • 1330 7th St, Sanger, CA 93657, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 559-399-8692
Pokeys Pinball Cafe
(321 review)
Pokeys Pinball Cafe
  • 211B 33rd St W, Saskatoon, SK S7L 0V2, Canada
cafe
+1 306-343-2196
Cafe Volan
(300 review)
Cafe Volan
  • Steinbach Building, 510 Bangs Ave, Asbury Park, NJ 07712, United States
Cafe
+1 732-455-3399
La Paella de Alicia Hipodromo
(315 review)
La Paella de Alicia Hipodromo
  • De las Ferias 377, Fracc. La Herradura, 22034 Tijuana, B.C., Mexico
spanish restaurant
+52 664 681 0019
Hinode Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi
(961 review)
Hinode Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi
  • 129 N Massey Blvd, Nixa, MO 65714, United States
Japanese restaurant
+1 417-374-7807
Char Bella
(105 review)
Char Bella
  • 2 Herbison Square, Ballymena BT43 6HS, United Kingdom
Restaurant
+44 28 2565 5773